On ACT English and Reading, as well as SAT Reading and Writing, many students follow the same pattern - read a question, then go straight to the answer choices to see which one sounds right. It feels efficient. But it’s one of the most common reasons strong readers miss questions they could have answered correctly.
Here’s why. The people who write the ACT and SAT are professional question writers. They’re experts at writing wrong answers that sound reasonable. When students let the answer choices do the thinking for them, they walk right into those traps.
The fix is simple: think first, then look.
Think before you look
Here’s the approach I teach students:
Read the question to know what it’s asking.
Read the passage, or the part the question points to.
Come up with their own answer before looking at the choices.
Find the choice that most closely matches their answer.
Confirm it with the text.
A student’s own answer doesn’t need to be fancy or formal. Casual is perfectly fine. “She’s kind of disappointed” works just as well as anything polished. The point is to have something to compare against, so the answer choices can’t steer their thinking.
Process of elimination is still a great strategy. It just works best after a student has taken a few seconds to think for themselves. With their own answer in mind, it’s much easier to spot the choices that don’t fit.
An example: transitions
Here’s a sentence with a missing transition:
Maya trained for months before the race. ______, she finished near the back of the pack.
Before looking at the choices, a student should ask: what word would I put there? Probably something like “but,” since the second sentence is a surprise.
Now the choices:
A. Similarly
B. However
C. Eventually
D. For example
With “but” in mind, B stands out right away. Without it, “Eventually” can seem fine. It reads smoothly, and she did finish the race eventually. But it misses the most important part: the result was the opposite of what anyone would expect after months of training. That’s exactly the kind of answer test writers are counting on.
An example: main idea
When a question asks for the main idea of a passage, students should pause and put it in their own words first. Something like, “This is about how community gardens bring neighbors together.” Then they look for the choice that matches.
This helps students avoid two common traps: a choice that’s true but only covers one detail, and a choice that sounds impressive but goes further than the passage does.
Why it works
Thinking first changes the student’s role. Instead of reacting to four choices that all sound possible, they walk in with an answer of their own and look for a match. It’s faster, more accurate, and a lot less stressful.
It does take a few extra seconds at first. With practice, it becomes a habit, and those seconds come back as fewer second guesses and fewer changed answers.
The ACT and SAT differ in passage length, but the approach is the same. In a future post, I’ll share how to adjust it slightly for the ACT, where passages are longer and come with more questions.
The bottom line
The answer choices aren’t there to help your student think. They’re there to test whether your student already has. Thinking first is how students outsmart the wrong answers that sound right.
If you missed my last post, I shared the biggest test prep mistake I see overall, and the targeted practice approach that works better.
If you’d like help figuring out where your student is losing points on the English, Reading, or Reading and Writing sections, I’d love to talk. You can book a 20-minute strategy call anytime.
Angie